VotePredictor
past elections

New York House

Nate McMurray (D) vs Chris Collins (R)

Actual result
D+4.8
Final polls said
R+2.5
3 late polls · ✗
Model predicted
R+5.5
Winner
Dem

"Final polls said" averages polls from the last ~3 weeks — the call right before the vote, and how pollsters are rated. The model's prediction is walk-forward (trained only on earlier races).

Final rankings

How everyone who called this race did, ranked — VotePredictor shown inline (★).

Pollsters — each pollster's final poll vs the result

#PollsterFinal callMissCalled
1Tulchin ResearchD+4.00.8
2Siena CollegeR+3.07.8
3The New York Times/Siena CollegeR+4.49.2
4VotePredictorR+5.510.3
5Dixie StrategiesR+7.212.0

Forecasters — pre-election win probability, scored by Brier

#ForecasterWin probBrierCalled
1VotePredictorRep 67%0.443
2DDHQ/Decision DeskRep 69%0.471
3The EconomistRep 70%0.486
4Cook PoliticalRep 75%0.562
5Sabato's Crystal BallRep 75%0.562
6FiveThirtyEightRep 80%0.640

Polls (5)

PollsterDatenPollMiss
Dixie Strategies2018-10-29801R+7.212
Tulchin Research2018-10-27400D+4.01
The New York Times/Siena College2018-10-26501R+4.49
Siena College2018-10-08490R+3.08
Tulchin Research2018-10-07400EVEN5