VotePredictor
← all race articles

Who won the Idaho Senate race? How the forecasts did

Result as reported Nov 14 · final forecasts frozen Nov 2, 12:46 PM EST · VotePredictor

Jim Risch won. VotePredictor's final forecast gave Risch a 99% chance and a margin of Risch +34.9 — the right call. Scored on one scale against every forecast below, it ranked 3 of 15.

VotePredictor final forecast
99% Risch

How the forecasts did

ForecasterFinal callChance for RischBrierRight?Margin miss
Polymarket100% Risch>99%0.000yes—
Kalshi100% Risch>99%0.000yes—
VotePredictor99% Risch, Risch +34.999%0.000yes—
Cook Political ReportSolid R99%0.000yes—
Decision Desk HQSolid R99%0.000yes—
The EconomistSolid R99%0.000yes—
FiftyPlusOneSolid R99%0.000yes—
Fox NewsSolid R99%0.000yes—
Inside ElectionsSolid R99%0.000yes—
MS NOWSolid R99%0.000yes—
NBC NewsSolid R99%0.000yes—
RealClearPoliticsSolid R99%0.000yes—
Sabato's Crystal BallSolid R99%0.000yes—
Silver BulletinSolid R99%0.000yes—
Split TicketSolid R99%0.000yes—
Poll averageRisch +32.0——no call—

Brier score is (forecast probability − outcome)², lower is better. Ratings are converted to a probability the way the rankings board converts them: Solid 99%, Likely 90%, Lean 75%, Tilt 60%, Toss-up 50%. Result source: en.wikipedia.org.

What the forecast is built on

The forecast starts from the 3 public polls in the forecast window, whose plain average is Risch +32.0. Each poll is corrected for its voter screen and its pollster's measured house effect first (the “Adjusted” column below).

  • The polls, weighted and corrected, read Risch +35.0.
  • The fundamentals (the state's presidential lean, incumbency, the last result and the national environment) read Risch +21.9.
  • The published forecast blends the two, mostly on the polls, at Risch +34.9.

How the forecast has moved

0255075100JulAugSepOctNov99% R1% D
Democrats 1% Republicans 99%
Hover to read any date
Each party's chance of winning in VotePredictor's forecast, rerun from the polls available on each date, through the final call. Hover or tap the chart to read any day; the dashed line is even odds.
DateRisch's chancePredicted margin
Jun 496%Risch +27.6
Jul 2>99%Risch +36.1
Aug 6>99%Risch +36.1
Sep 1>99%Risch +31.9
Oct 1>99%Risch +35.2
Oct 26>99%Risch +33.6
Nov 1>99%Risch +34.9
Nov 2 (final)99%Risch +34.9

The polls

3 polls are in the final forecast. Margins are Democrat minus Republican.

The polls behind it

3 polls · newest first

Each pollster name links to the poll's source; the grade under it is its VotePredictor grade from past elections. Margin is the poll as published. The ± under the sample size is the 95% margin of error on each candidate's share, from the sample size (the gap between them is about twice as uncertain). VotePredictor adjusted (“Our adj.” on small screens) is not a poll: it is our correction of that poll, for its pollster's record in past elections and for registered-voter or all-adult samples. It is the number our forecast reads.

PollsterDateMarginOur adj.
Change Research (via Wikipedia)Grade B-07-30R+30.0R+33.5
Peak Insights (via Wikipedia)06-07R+40.0R+40.7
The Bullfinch Group (via Wikipedia)06-01R+17.0R+17.7

Can you trust this forecast?

Every VotePredictor forecast is scored after the election against the same outcomes as everyone else's. Across 614 past races (Senate, governor, House and president), our final forecasts rank #2 of every forecaster that covered them all (Brier score 0.076, lower is better); FiveThirtyEight is first at 0.072. The full record is on the forecaster rankings and methodology pages.

This article is regenerated every day from the VotePredictor forecast, the poll database, the prediction markets and the rating shops' latest published ratings. Live numbers are on the race page.