VotePredictor
← Back to ratings

Silver Bulletin

Forecaster quality, broken out by office and by cycle. Scored on the Brier score of its final pre-election win probability (lower is better), over 40 races, 2016–2024.

Overall Brier
0.045
Races scored
40

Head-to-head vs the VotePredictor model

Apples-to-apples: on the 40 races Silver Bulletin forecast, its win-probability Brier vs VotePredictor's calibrated win-prob on those same races.

ModelBrierCalled right
Silver Bulletin0.04595%
VotePredictor0.013100%

Every race (40)

Each race Silver Bulletin scored, with its final pre-election call vs who actually won, and the Brier score for that call. Click a race for its full detail.

RaceTheir callWinnerBrierCalled
2024 AK PresidentRep 77%Rep0.052
2024 AZ PresidentRep 72%Rep0.080
2024 CA PresidentDem 100%Dem0.000
2024 CO PresidentDem 99%Dem0.000
2024 FL PresidentRep 93%Rep0.005
2024 GA PresidentRep 59%Rep0.169
2024 IA PresidentRep 85%Rep0.023
2024 MA PresidentDem 100%Dem0.000
2024 MD PresidentDem 100%Dem0.000
2024 ME PresidentDem 87%Dem0.016
2024 ME-1 PresidentDem 99%Dem0.000
2024 ME-2 PresidentRep 76%Rep0.056
2024 MI PresidentDem 62%Rep0.382
2024 MN PresidentDem 86%Dem0.018
2024 MO PresidentRep 100%Rep0.000
2024 MT PresidentRep 98%Rep0.000
2024 NC PresidentRep 61%Rep0.149
2024 NE PresidentRep 100%Rep0.000
2024 NE-1 PresidentRep 100%Rep0.000
2024 NE-2 PresidentDem 93%Dem0.005
2024 NE-3 PresidentRep 100%Rep0.000
2024 NH PresidentDem 86%Dem0.020
2024 NJ PresidentDem 99%Dem0.000
2024 NM PresidentDem 87%Dem0.017
2024 NV PresidentRep 54%Rep0.209
2024 NY PresidentDem 100%Dem0.000
2024 OH PresidentRep 97%Rep0.001
2024 OK PresidentRep 100%Rep0.000
2024 OR PresidentDem 97%Dem0.001
2024 PA PresidentRep 51%Rep0.237
2024 RI PresidentDem 99%Dem0.000
2024 SC PresidentRep 99%Rep0.000
2024 SD PresidentRep 99%Rep0.000
2024 TX PresidentRep 97%Rep0.001
2024 UT PresidentRep 99%Rep0.000
2024 VA PresidentDem 94%Dem0.004
2024 VT PresidentDem 100%Dem0.000
2024 WA PresidentDem 100%Dem0.000
2024 WI PresidentDem 59%Rep0.349
2024 WY PresidentRep 100%Rep0.000

By office

By cycle

YearRacesBrierCalled right
2024400.04595%

Why no “time to election” curve? Unlike pollsters — where we have every poll with its field dates — our forecaster archive (JHK Forecasts) stores only each outfit's final pre-election forecast per race, not its earlier snapshots. So a lead-time breakdown genuinely isn't in the data for forecasters. Pollster pages do show it (e.g. the leaderboard).