VotePredictor
← Back to ratings

RealClearPolitics vs VotePredictor

Forecaster quality, broken out by office and by cycle. Scored on the Brier score of its final pre-election win probability (lower is better), over 342 races, 2016–2024, and compared with our forecast on every one of them.

Overall Brier
0.118
Races scored
342

RealClearPolitics vs VotePredictor Elections

Apples-to-apples: on the 214 races RealClearPolitics forecast, its win-probability Brier vs VotePredictor Elections' calibrated win-prob on those same races.

ModelBrierCalled right
RealClearPolitics0.12774%
VotePredictor Elections0.07090%

Every pollster and forecaster against us: head-to-head.

RealClearPolitics against every other forecaster and market

Paired with each forecaster and prediction market on only the races both of them called, so neither is helped by easier races. The blue dot is RealClearPolitics, the grey dot the other forecaster; the line is green where RealClearPolitics scored the better Brier and red where it scored worse.

RealClearPolitics: Brier 0.118 on all 342 of these races · picked the winner in 93% · better than 0 of 15 forecasters and markets on their own races.

RealClearPoliticsThemBrier, lower is better · hover a row for the numbers

# = rank on the overall leaderboard, which orders this list

  • #1FiveThirtyEight282 racesWorse · closer in 21%
  • #4VotePredictor Elections342 racesWorse · closer in 21%
  • #7JHK Forecasts214 racesWorse · closer in 18%
  • #8Cook Political331 racesWorse · closer in 18%
  • #9Race to the WH214 racesWorse · closer in 21%
  • #10Sabato's Crystal Ball342 racesWorse · closer in 18%
  • #11The Economist214 racesWorse · closer in 19%
  • #12Inside Elections342 racesWorse · closer in 20%
  • #13Fox News202 racesWorse · closer in 25%
  • #14Split Ticket134 racesWorse · closer in 27%
  • #16DDHQ/Decision Desk214 racesWorse · closer in 29%
  • #18PredictIt68 racesWorse · closer in 22%
  • #21Princeton Election Consortium80 racesWorse · closer in 18%
  • #22Elections Daily253 racesWorse · closer in 14%
  • #24CNalysis220 racesWorse · closer in 19%
0.0490.162

Every race, side by side (342)

Each race RealClearPolitics scored: its final pre-election call next to ours for the same race, against who actually won. Closer says whose probability scored the better Brier (hover for both). Green where VotePredictor was closer, red where they were. Click a race for its full detail.

On the 342 races we both called, VotePredictor was closer in 197 and RealClearPolitics in 51 (94 tied).

RaceTheir callOur callWinnerCloser
2024 MO GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2024 NC GovernorDem 90%Dem 98%DemUs
2024 NH GovernorEvenRep 63%RepUs
2024 UT GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2024 VT GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2024 WA GovernorDem 90%Dem 96%DemUs
2024 AK-1 HouseEvenRep 93%RepUs
2024 AL-2 HouseDem 90%Dem 88%DemThem
2024 CA-22 HouseRep 75%Dem 67%RepThem
2024 CA-47 HouseEvenDem 65%DemUs
2024 CA-49 HouseDem 90%Dem 93%DemUs
2024 CA-51 HouseDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2024 CO-8 HouseEvenDem 59%RepThem
2024 CT-5 HouseEvenDem 80%DemUs
2024 FL-13 HouseRep 99%Rep 94%RepThem
2024 FL-4 HouseRep 99%Rep 98%RepTie
2024 GA-2 HouseDem 90%Dem 90%DemTie
2024 IA-1 HouseEvenRep 52%RepUs
2024 IA-2 HouseRep 75%Rep 93%RepUs
2024 IA-3 HouseRep 75%Rep 67%RepThem
2024 IA-4 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2024 IL-17 HouseDem 99%Dem 77%DemThem
2024 ME-1 HouseDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2024 ME-2 HouseEvenRep 65%DemThem
2024 MI-10 HouseEvenRep 86%RepUs
2024 MI-7 HouseEvenRep 76%RepUs
2024 MT-1 HouseRep 90%Rep 94%RepUs
2024 NE-1 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2024 NE-2 HouseEvenRep 52%RepUs
2024 NE-3 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2024 NH-1 HouseEvenDem 96%DemUs
2024 NH-2 HouseDem 75%Dem 98%DemUs
2024 NY-1 HouseRep 75%Rep 88%RepUs
2024 NY-17 HouseEvenRep 60%RepUs
2024 NY-18 HouseDem 90%Dem 87%DemThem
2024 NY-22 HouseEvenDem 55%DemUs
2024 NY-3 HouseDem 90%Dem 79%DemThem
2024 NY-4 HouseEvenDem 82%DemUs
2024 OH-13 HouseEvenRep 55%DemThem
2024 PA-8 HouseEvenRep 56%RepUs
2024 SD-1 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2024 VA-2 HouseEvenRep 75%RepUs
2024 VA-7 HouseEvenDem 57%DemUs
2024 VT-1 HouseDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 AK GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2022 AL GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 AR GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 AZ GovernorEvenRep 88%DemThem
2022 CA GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 CO GovernorDem 90%Dem 99%DemUs
2022 CT GovernorDem 75%Dem 100%DemUs
2022 FL GovernorRep 75%Rep 99%RepUs
2022 GA GovernorRep 75%Rep 99%RepUs
2022 IA GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2022 IL GovernorDem 75%Dem 98%DemUs
2022 KS GovernorEvenDem 73%DemUs
2022 MA GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 MD GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 ME GovernorEvenDem 95%DemUs
2022 MI GovernorEvenDem 81%DemUs
2022 MN GovernorEvenDem 93%DemUs
2022 NE GovernorRep 99%Rep 95%RepThem
2022 NH GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 NM GovernorEvenDem 87%DemUs
2022 NV GovernorEvenRep 69%RepUs
2022 NY GovernorEvenDem 92%DemUs
2022 OH GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 OK GovernorEvenRep 95%RepUs
2022 OR GovernorEvenRep 52%DemThem
2022 PA GovernorDem 75%Dem 96%DemUs
2022 RI GovernorDem 90%Dem 97%DemUs
2022 SD GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2022 TN GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 TX GovernorRep 75%Rep 100%RepUs
2022 VT GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 WI GovernorEvenRep 57%DemThem
2022 WY GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 AK-1 HouseEvenDem 70%DemUs
2022 CA-21 HouseDem 90%Dem 91%DemUs
2022 CA-26 HouseDem 75%Dem 94%DemUs
2022 CA-27 HouseRep 75%Dem 71%RepThem
2022 CA-41 HouseRep 75%Rep 84%RepUs
2022 CA-49 HouseEvenDem 84%DemUs
2022 CO-3 HouseRep 90%Rep 84%RepThem
2022 CO-8 HouseRep 75%Rep 86%DemThem
2022 CT-2 HouseDem 75%Dem 98%DemUs
2022 CT-4 HouseDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 CT-5 HouseEvenDem 70%DemUs
2022 DE-1 HouseDem 99%Dem 99%DemTie
2022 FL-1 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 FL-13 HouseRep 90%Rep 82%RepThem
2022 FL-15 HouseRep 90%Rep 89%RepThem
2022 FL-2 HouseRep 99%Rep 97%RepThem
2022 FL-27 HouseRep 90%Rep 82%RepThem
2022 FL-28 HouseRep 90%Rep 98%RepUs
2022 FL-4 HouseRep 90%Rep 97%RepUs
2022 GA-2 HouseEvenDem 69%DemUs
2022 IA-3 HouseRep 75%Rep 64%RepThem
2022 IL-10 HouseDem 99%Dem 99%DemTie
2022 IL-17 HouseRep 75%Dem 75%DemUs
2022 KS-2 HouseRep 99%Rep 98%RepTie
2022 KS-3 HouseEvenDem 85%DemUs
2022 MD-1 HouseRep 99%Rep 99%RepTie
2022 MD-2 HouseDem 90%Dem 98%DemUs
2022 MD-6 HouseEvenDem 79%DemUs
2022 ME-1 HouseDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 ME-2 HouseEvenDem 54%DemUs
2022 MI-10 HouseRep 90%Rep 80%RepThem
2022 MI-7 HouseEvenDem 82%DemUs
2022 MI-8 HouseEvenRep 55%DemThem
2022 MN-1 HouseRep 90%Rep 98%RepUs
2022 MN-2 HouseRep 75%Dem 63%DemUs
2022 MT-1 HouseRep 90%Rep 84%RepThem
2022 MT-2 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 NC-1 HouseEvenDem 88%DemUs
2022 NC-13 HouseRep 75%Dem 52%DemUs
2022 NH-1 HouseRep 75%Dem 69%DemUs
2022 NH-2 HouseEvenDem 92%DemUs
2022 NJ-7 HouseRep 75%Dem 52%RepThem
2022 NM-1 HouseDem 75%Dem 93%DemUs
2022 NM-2 HouseRep 75%Rep 65%DemUs
2022 NM-3 HouseDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2022 NV-1 HouseRep 75%Rep 60%DemUs
2022 NV-2 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 NV-3 HouseRep 75%EvenDemUs
2022 NV-4 HouseEvenDem 72%DemUs
2022 NY-11 HouseRep 99%Rep 73%RepThem
2022 NY-17 HouseEvenRep 67%RepUs
2022 NY-19 HouseEvenDem 75%RepThem
2022 NY-22 HouseRep 75%Dem 54%RepThem
2022 NY-25 HouseEvenDem 89%DemUs
2022 OH-1 HouseRep 75%Dem 60%DemUs
2022 OH-13 HouseRep 75%Rep 54%DemUs
2022 OR-4 HouseEvenDem 67%DemUs
2022 OR-6 HouseEvenRep 71%DemThem
2022 PA-12 HouseDem 75%Dem 98%DemUs
2022 PA-17 HouseRep 75%Dem 73%DemUs
2022 PA-7 HouseRep 75%Rep 54%DemUs
2022 PA-8 HouseRep 75%Dem 50%DemUs
2022 RI-2 HouseRep 75%Rep 52%DemUs
2022 TX-15 HouseRep 75%Rep 79%RepUs
2022 VA-10 HouseDem 75%Dem 89%DemUs
2022 VA-2 HouseRep 75%Rep 53%RepThem
2022 VA-7 HouseEvenDem 62%DemUs
2022 VT-1 HouseDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 WA-3 HouseRep 90%Rep 91%DemThem
2022 WY-1 HouseRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 AL SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 AR SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 AZ SenateEvenDem 65%DemUs
2022 CA SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 CO SenateEvenDem 96%DemUs
2022 CT SenateDem 75%Dem 100%DemUs
2022 FL SenateRep 75%Rep 99%RepUs
2022 GA SenateEvenDem 52%DemUs
2022 IA SenateRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2022 IL SenateDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2022 IN SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 KS SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 MD SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 MO SenateRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2022 NC SenateRep 75%Rep 92%RepUs
2022 NH SenateEvenDem 77%DemUs
2022 NV SenateEvenRep 60%DemThem
2022 NY SenateDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2022 OH SenateRep 75%Rep 94%RepUs
2022 OK SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 OR SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 PA SenateEvenRep 51%DemThem
2022 SD SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2022 VT SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2022 WA SenateEvenDem 94%DemUs
2022 WI SenateEvenRep 93%RepUs
2020 AK PresidentRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 AL PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 AR PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 AZ PresidentEvenDem 55%DemUs
2020 CA PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 CO PresidentDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2020 CT PresidentDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 DC PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 DE PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 FL PresidentEvenRep 58%RepUs
2020 GA PresidentEvenRep 67%DemThem
2020 HI PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 IA PresidentEvenRep 78%RepUs
2020 ID PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 IL PresidentDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 IN PresidentRep 75%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 KS PresidentRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 KY PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 LA PresidentRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 MA PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 MD PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 ME PresidentDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2020 MI PresidentEvenDem 93%DemUs
2020 MN PresidentEvenDem 96%DemUs
2020 MO PresidentRep 75%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 MS PresidentRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 MT PresidentRep 75%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 NC PresidentEvenRep 50%RepUs
2020 ND PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 NE PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 NH PresidentDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2020 NJ PresidentDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 NM PresidentDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2020 NV PresidentEvenDem 63%DemUs
2020 NY PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 OH PresidentEvenRep 85%RepUs
2020 OK PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 OR PresidentDem 75%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 PA PresidentEvenDem 71%DemUs
2020 RI PresidentDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 SC PresidentRep 75%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 SD PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 TN PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 TX PresidentEvenRep 87%RepUs
2020 UT PresidentRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 VA PresidentDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2020 VT PresidentDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 WA PresidentDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 WI PresidentEvenDem 91%DemUs
2020 WV PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 WY PresidentRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 AK SenateRep 75%Rep 94%RepUs
2020 AL SenateRep 90%Rep 99%RepUs
2020 CO SenateDem 75%Dem 91%DemUs
2020 DE SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 GA SenateEvenRep 80%RepUs
2020 IA SenateEvenRep 77%RepUs
2020 IL SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 KS SenateRep 75%Rep 93%RepUs
2020 KY SenateRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 MA SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 ME SenateEvenRep 58%RepUs
2020 MI SenateEvenDem 98%DemUs
2020 MN SenateEvenDem 99%DemUs
2020 MS SenateRep 75%Rep 99%RepUs
2020 MT SenateEvenRep 95%RepUs
2020 NC SenateEvenDem 53%RepThem
2020 NE SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 NH SenateDem 75%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 NJ SenateDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 NM SenateDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2020 OK SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 OR SenateDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2020 SC SenateEvenRep 96%RepUs
2020 SD SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 TN SenateRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2020 TX SenateRep 75%Rep 98%RepUs
2020 VA SenateDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2020 WV SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2020 WY SenateRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 AK GovernorEvenRep 98%RepUs
2018 AL GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 AR GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 AZ GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2018 CA GovernorDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2018 CO GovernorDem 75%Dem 91%DemUs
2018 CT GovernorEvenDem 87%DemUs
2018 FL GovernorEvenDem 77%RepThem
2018 GA GovernorEvenRep 58%RepUs
2018 HI GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2018 IA GovernorEvenDem 54%RepThem
2018 ID GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 IL GovernorDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2018 KS GovernorEvenRep 66%DemThem
2018 MA GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 MD GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2018 ME GovernorDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2018 MI GovernorDem 75%Dem 95%DemUs
2018 MN GovernorDem 75%Dem 96%DemUs
2018 NH GovernorEvenRep 94%RepUs
2018 NM GovernorDem 75%Dem 96%DemUs
2018 NV GovernorEvenRep 61%DemThem
2018 NY GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2018 OH GovernorEvenDem 56%RepThem
2018 OK GovernorRep 75%Rep 93%RepUs
2018 OR GovernorEvenDem 89%DemUs
2018 PA GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2018 RI GovernorDem 90%Dem 99%DemUs
2018 SC GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 SD GovernorEvenRep 60%RepUs
2018 TN GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2018 TX GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2018 VT GovernorRep 90%Rep 99%RepUs
2018 WI GovernorEvenRep 59%DemThem
2018 WY GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2016 DE GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2016 IN GovernorEvenDem 55%RepThem
2016 MO GovernorEvenDem 59%RepThem
2016 MT GovernorDem 75%Dem 72%DemThem
2016 NC GovernorEvenRep 58%DemThem
2016 ND GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2016 NH GovernorEvenDem 69%RepThem
2016 UT GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2016 VT GovernorEvenRep 77%RepUs
2016 WA GovernorDem 75%Dem 96%DemUs
2016 WV GovernorRep 75%Rep 70%DemUs
2014 AL GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2014 AR GovernorRep 75%Rep 92%RepUs
2014 AZ GovernorRep 75%Rep 91%RepUs
2014 CA GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2014 CO GovernorEvenDem 74%DemUs
2014 CT GovernorEvenDem 68%DemUs
2014 FL GovernorEvenRep 69%RepUs
2014 GA GovernorEvenRep 92%RepUs
2014 HI GovernorDem 90%Dem 97%DemUs
2014 IA GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2014 ID GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2014 IL GovernorEvenDem 59%RepThem
2014 KS GovernorEvenRep 75%RepUs
2014 MA GovernorEvenRep 59%RepUs
2014 MD GovernorEvenDem 67%RepThem
2014 ME GovernorEvenRep 77%RepUs
2014 MI GovernorEvenRep 82%RepUs
2014 MN GovernorDem 75%Dem 93%DemUs
2014 NE GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2014 NH GovernorEvenDem 94%DemUs
2014 NM GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2014 NV GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2014 NY GovernorDem 99%Dem 100%DemTie
2014 OH GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2014 OK GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2014 OR GovernorDem 75%Dem 96%DemUs
2014 PA GovernorDem 90%Dem 90%DemUs
2014 RI GovernorEvenDem 73%DemUs
2014 SC GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2014 SD GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2014 TN GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2014 TX GovernorRep 90%Rep 100%RepUs
2014 VT GovernorDem 90%Dem 100%DemUs
2014 WI GovernorEvenRep 81%RepUs
2014 WY GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2012 IN GovernorRep 90%Rep 98%RepUs
2012 MO GovernorDem 75%Dem 99%DemUs
2012 MT GovernorEvenRep 52%DemThem
2012 NC GovernorRep 90%Rep 99%RepUs
2012 ND GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2012 NH GovernorDem 75%Dem 72%DemThem
2012 UT GovernorRep 99%Rep 100%RepTie
2012 WA GovernorEvenDem 71%DemUs

By office

OfficeRacesBrierCalled right
Governor1280.10299%
House1080.17380%
Senate550.087100%

By cycle

YearRacesBrierCalled right
2014350.103100%
2018350.098100%
2020800.078100%
20221290.15284%
2024440.111100%

Why no “time to election” curve? Unlike pollsters — where we have every poll with its field dates — our forecaster archive (JHK Forecasts) stores only each outfit's final pre-election forecast per race, not its earlier snapshots. So a lead-time breakdown genuinely isn't in the data for forecasters. Pollster pages do show it (e.g. the leaderboard).